Skip to main content

Across the Miles: A Modern Family and an Outdated Ideal

Yet, across the miles, his personal life remained a mystery – a man on his third marital quest, living in a country struggling to define what family truly meant....

The man on the phone wasn’t in Ireland. At least, not right now. Evidence pointed towards a messy desk – a chaotic sprawl of mugs, half-eaten donuts, and the tell-tale glint of a permanent marker amongst the usual phone clutter. A picture on the screen, however, offered a glimpse into his life – a beaming toddler, a recent addition to his family.

He’d remarried quickly after a tumultuous first marriage, rumors swirling about the reason for the split. Now, with a child barely out of diapers and a wife who, like him, carried the baggage of a previous divorce, whispers surrounded him again. He was, it seemed, on the hunt for wife number three.

Meanwhile, in Ireland, a battle over family values raged. The public soundly rejected attempts to modernize the constitution, clinging to the traditional definition of family and the outdated notion of a woman’s place being in the home. This stood in stark contrast to the reality of modern Ireland, where families came in all shapes and sizes, and women were a vital part of the workforce.

The government, with bipartisan support, had proposed changes recognizing families beyond marriage and spreading the responsibility of caregiving. However, their efforts were hampered by a lack of clarity on legalities, particularly around inheritance, which fueled anxieties in a nation obsessed with property rights. Additionally, their attempt to address the archaic “women in the home” clause felt half-hearted, watered down from recommendations made by committees specifically focused on gender equality.

Ireland's effort to remove old-fashioned family values from its constitution
Voters rejected amendments
Amendments seen as maddeningly vague
Amendments seen as threatening to property rights
Double defeat for Ireland's effort

The man on the phone, with his unconventional family situation, might have embodied the very changes Ireland was grappling with. Yet, across the miles, his personal life remained a mystery – a man on his third marital quest, living in a country struggling to define what family truly meant.


Irish voters reject bid to rewrite constitution’s view of women and family

Comments