Poland's Political Earthquake: Nationalism, Anti-Immigration, and the Unraveling of Humanitarian Aid

In the heart of Poland, a political earthquake rattled the nation. The newly elected historian and author, Nawrocki, used his swearing-in speech to parliament as a platform for a stark, two-pronged declaration: “No to illegal immigration, no to the euro.” This was no surprise to those who had followed his campaign, a period marked by a surge in nationalist rhetoric and pointed criticism of Ukrainian refugees seeking solace within Poland’s borders. His victory, however, sent tremors of unease both domestically and internationally.

Nawrocki’s rhetoric, as highlighted by Oleksandr Pestrykov of the Ukrainian House Foundation in Warsaw, is dangerously legitimizing anti-Ukrainian sentiment. Pestrykov warns that this is a form of social segregation, creating an environment where previously “ashamed” anti-Ukrainian voices can now be expressed “openly.” This shift in public discourse, Pestrykov argues, is a direct result of a leader who openly described Ukrainian refugees as “ungrateful” and a “burden on society.”

Nawrocki’s campaign slogan, “Poland First, Poles First,” encapsulated his vision. He pledged to prioritize Polish citizens in healthcare and education, cut pensions for Ukrainians, and restrict benefits to Poles only. This policy platform, and the rhetoric that supports it, illustrates a dangerous unraveling of the social contract between aid providers and recipients. The premise that a clear financial gap is necessary for humanitarian compassion to flourish, and that the weakening of this gap breeds “jealousy, suspicion, a sense of unfairness, and hatred,” appears to be playing out in real-time.

Nawrocki’s political ascent suggests that the “rewards and limits of humanitarian aid” were not clearly defined or shared. The social compact, the understanding of what aid entails and what its boundaries are, has been breached. As the perceived financial burden of supporting refugees grew, a sense of unfairness seems to have taken root. This fertile ground for resentment was expertly tilled by Nawrocki’s campaign, which capitalized on these anxieties and redirected them into a potent political force. His victory and subsequent rhetoric serve as a stark warning: when the delicate balance of humanitarian aid is upset, the very compassion that underpins it can swiftly curdle into hatred.

Poland’s new president brings hard line on refugees, abortion and rule of law